Do I Have to Repair My Car After Receiving Insurance Money? What You Need to Know

Introduction

Being involved in a car accident is a stressful experience. After the initial shock and paperwork, dealing with insurance claims can feel overwhelming. A common question that arises after receiving an insurance settlement check is: Do I have to repair my car after receiving insurance money? It’s a valid question, and understanding your obligations and options is crucial to making informed decisions.

This guide, brought to you by Car Repair Online experts, will walk you through what you need to know about car repairs after an accident and receiving insurance funds. We’ll clarify your rights, explore the common misconceptions, and provide essential information to help you navigate this process smoothly and confidently. Whether you’ve experienced a minor fender bender or a more significant collision on California roads, this comprehensive guide will help you understand your responsibilities and make the best choices for your vehicle and your peace of mind.

Understanding your auto insurance policy is the first step in navigating post-accident scenarios. Carefully review your insurance application and declaration page when you first purchase your policy. This document outlines your coverages, policy limits, and deductibles, ensuring they align with your needs. If any changes are necessary, always communicate with your agent or insurance company in writing, keeping copies for your records and using certified mail for important submissions. Familiarizing yourself with your policy details beforehand will empower you when you need to file a claim.

Back to Top

What Happens After an Accident and Filing a Claim?

Q. What are the first steps after a car accident?

A. Safety and Information First.

• STOP Immediately and move to a safe location if possible and safe to do so, away from traffic flow.
• Check for injuries and Call 911 if anyone is injured. Your immediate priority is safety and medical assistance.
• Contact the Police. Even for seemingly minor accidents, it’s advisable to call the police. They can create an official accident report, which is often helpful for insurance claims. Note that in some areas, police response may vary depending on accident severity or location (e.g., private property). However, attempting to notify the police is always recommended. Be aware that most insurance policies require police notification within a specific timeframe, especially in hit-and-run incidents.
• Exchange Information with all Drivers. Collect essential details from all involved parties:
  • Full Names, Addresses, and Phone Numbers
  • Driver’s License Numbers
  • License Plate Numbers and Vehicle Identification Numbers (VIN). It’s wise to visually verify this information by asking to see driver’s licenses and vehicle registrations.
• Gather Witness Information. Obtain names, addresses, and phone numbers of any passengers and witnesses present at the scene.
• Document the Scene. If you have a camera or smartphone, take pictures of:
  • Vehicle damage (all angles and close-ups).
  • The accident scene, including road conditions, traffic signals, signs, and visibility factors.
• Leave a Note if Necessary. If you damage an unattended vehicle or property and cannot locate the owner, leave a clearly visible note with your name, address, and contact information, as well as the driver and owner details of your car.
• Notify Your Insurance Agent and/or Insurance Company Immediately. Promptly reporting the accident is crucial to initiating the claims process.
• Report to the DMV if Required. In California, if anyone is injured or property damage exceeds $750, you must report the accident to the Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) within 10 days. Failure to do so can lead to driver’s license suspension.

Back to Top

Frequently Asked Questions About Car Repair and Insurance Payouts

Q. After I file a claim, what’s the insurance claim process?

A. Once you’ve filed a claim, your insurance company will begin an investigation. Expect the following steps:

• Contact from the Insurance Company: An insurance adjuster will contact you to gather detailed information about the accident. They may request a recorded statement or a written statement about the incident. In some cases, they may request an Examination Under Oath (EUO), which is a more formal interview under oath.
• Investigation: The insurance company will investigate the accident to determine fault and the extent of damages. This may involve contacting other drivers, witnesses, and reviewing police reports.
• Documentation for Certain Claims: If you’re filing a claim for medical payments or under uninsured motorist coverage, you’ll need to provide documentation of your losses, such as medical bills, records of lost wages, and other relevant expenses.

Q. What if my insurance company is slow to respond?

A. Insurance companies are expected to handle claims promptly. In California, insurers are generally expected to contact you within a reasonable timeframe after you report a loss. While the specific timeframe can depend on circumstances, insurers in California typically should contact you within 15 days of receiving notice of your claim. If you haven’t heard from a claim representative within this period, take action:

• Contact Your Agent or Insurance Company Directly: Call them to inquire about the status of your claim.
• Escalate if Necessary: If you experience unresponsiveness or unreasonable delays, contact the California Department of Insurance (CDI). The CDI can assist in resolving disputes and ensuring fair claim handling.

Q. How will the insurance company assess the damage to my car?

A. The insurance company will evaluate the damage to your vehicle to determine the repair costs or if it’s a total loss. Here’s the typical process:

• Vehicle Inspection: A qualified insurance adjuster or appraiser will inspect your damaged vehicle. They will assess the damage and prepare an initial repair estimate.
• Supplemental Damage: Often, during the repair process, body shops discover additional (“hidden” or “supplemental”) damage. If this happens, the repair shop will contact your insurer for approval to cover the extra repair costs. The insurer may send an adjuster to re-inspect the vehicle for these supplemental damages.
• Competitive Estimates (For Minor Damage): For less extensive damage, the insurance company might ask you to obtain multiple repair estimates from different body shops.
• Your Authorization to Repair: Remember, ultimately, it’s your decision to authorize the repair shop to begin work on your vehicle once you agree with the final estimate and choose a repair facility.

Q. What will my insurance company actually pay for on a vehicle damage claim?

A. In most standard auto insurance policies, the insurance company will pay the lesser of these two amounts:

• The Cost to Repair the Vehicle: This is the amount needed to restore your car to its pre-accident condition.
• The Actual Cash Value (ACV) of the Vehicle: This is the market value of your car right before it was damaged.

Your policy dictates the specifics of your coverage, so always review your policy carefully, paying close attention to exclusions and limitations. For example, standard policies often have limited or no coverage for aftermarket stereo systems, phones, or custom wheels and tires, unless they were original equipment from the manufacturer (OEM). You can usually purchase additional coverage for such aftermarket equipment at an extra cost.

Q. What exactly is “Actual Cash Value” (ACV)?

A. Actual Cash Value (ACV) is a key term in insurance. In California, unless your policy defines it differently, ACV means fair market value. Fair market value is the price a willing buyer would pay and a willing seller would accept for an item, assuming both parties are knowledgeable about the item and acting in their own best interest without pressure. Factors considered in determining ACV include your car’s age, mileage, condition before the accident, and typical market prices for similar vehicles in your area.

Q. What is an appraisal provision, and how can it help me?

A. Most auto policies include an appraisal provision, which can be useful if you disagree with the insurance company’s valuation of your vehicle, especially in a total loss situation.

• How it Works: Either you or the insurance company can invoke the appraisal provision. Each party hires their own appraiser. These two appraisers then select a neutral third appraiser, called an umpire.
• Resolution: The appraisers try to reach an agreement on the vehicle’s value. If they disagree, they submit their differing valuations to the umpire. An agreement by any two of the three (the two appraisers, or one appraiser and the umpire) is considered binding.
• Costs: You and the insurance company each pay for your own appraiser. The cost of the umpire is shared equally.

Q. How will I receive payment for my claim?

A. Insurance claim payments are typically issued by check or draft.

• Payees: The payment check may be made out to:
  • You (the insured).
  • Any lienholder (like a bank or finance company if you have a car loan).
  • If your car is being repaired, the check might also include the repair facility as a payee. This is common to ensure the repair shop gets paid directly.

Q. What happens if my car is totaled and I still owe money on my car loan?

A. You are still responsible for your car loan balance, even if your car is totaled or stolen. If the insurance payout is less than your outstanding loan balance, you will have to pay the difference to the lender.

• “Gap” Insurance: To protect against this situation, you can purchase “gap” insurance. Gap insurance covers the “gap” between what your car is worth (its ACV) and what you still owe on your loan, in case of a total loss.

Q. Will my insurance pay for a rental car while my car is being repaired?

A. Yes, but only if you have rental car coverage (often called “rental reimbursement coverage”) as part of your policy.

• Rental Coverage Details: Review your policy for the specifics of your rental coverage. It usually pays up to a daily limit and for a maximum number of days. Coverage typically ends when your car repairs are completed, when the insurance company pays for the loss (e.g., in a total loss), or after the specified coverage period, whichever comes first.
• Transportation Expenses for Stolen Vehicles: If your car is stolen, some policies automatically include transportation expense coverage. Again, check your policy. This coverage usually starts 48 hours after the theft and ends when your car is recovered, the loss is paid, or after a policy-defined period.

Q. What is a Collision Damage Waiver (CDW) when renting a car, and will my insurance cover it?

A. When you rent a car, the rental agreement usually makes you responsible for damage to the rental vehicle, including collision damage. Rental companies also offer their own insurance for damage. A Collision Damage Waiver (CDW) is an optional service offered by rental companies. For an extra fee, the rental company will waive your responsibility to pay for collision damage to the rental car.

• CDW Coverage and Your Personal Auto Policy: Whether your personal auto insurance policy covers CDW charges for a rental car depends on your policy’s terms. Carefully read your policy or ask your agent or insurance company about rental car coverage before you rent a vehicle. Often, your collision and comprehensive coverage will extend to rental cars, but liability coverage might be separate.

Back to Top

Q. What is “salvage value” in an insurance claim?

A. Salvage value refers to the remaining value of your damaged vehicle if it’s declared a total loss. If your car is totaled, the insurance company will pay you its ACV. They may then take possession of the damaged vehicle (the “salvage”). The salvage value is the estimated amount they can get by selling the damaged car for parts or scrap. You may have the option to keep your totaled vehicle (if it’s repairable, or for parts, or sentimental reasons), but the insurance company will deduct the salvage value from your settlement.

Q. What is “subrogation” in insurance?

A. Subrogation is an important insurance concept. It’s the insurance company’s right to legally recover the money they paid you for a claim from a responsible third party.

• Example: If another driver is at fault in an accident that damages your car, and you file a collision claim with your insurance company, your insurer will pay for your repairs. Then, through subrogation, your insurance company will attempt to recover the money they paid from the at-fault driver’s insurance company (or the at-fault driver directly).
• Your Cooperation: Your insurance policy requires you to cooperate with your company’s subrogation efforts.
• No Release Agreements: You cannot take any action that would harm the insurance company’s ability to recover funds through subrogation. For example, you shouldn’t sign a release agreement with the at-fault party in exchange for them paying your deductible without consulting your insurer.

Q. Is my insurance company required to help me get my deductible back?

A. The answer is nuanced.

• Company’s Subrogation Efforts: Your insurance company must inform you if they intend to pursue subrogation against the at-fault party. If they do pursue subrogation, they are required to include your deductible in their recovery efforts.
• No Subrogation: If the insurance company decides not to pursue subrogation, they must inform you of this, allowing you to pursue your deductible recovery on your own directly from the at-fault party.
• Deductible Reimbursement: If the insurance company is successful in subrogation (fully or partially), they will reimburse you for your deductible, proportionate to the amount they recover. For instance, if they recover 100% of the claim costs, you get 100% of your deductible back. If they recover 65%, you get 65% of your deductible.
• Apportioned Expenses: Any legal or recovery fees the insurance company incurs during subrogation are typically shared proportionally between you and the company, if a recovery is made.
• Independent Recovery: You have the option to try and recover your deductible yourself, directly from the at-fault party. However, always discuss this with your insurance company first to avoid potentially jeopardizing their subrogation rights.

Q. Am I covered if I drive my car outside of California?

A. Yes, generally, most auto insurance policies extend coverage to other U.S. states, territories, possessions, and Canada.

• Financial Responsibility Laws: Like California, most states and territories have financial responsibility laws requiring drivers to carry minimum auto insurance.
• Meeting Higher Limits: If the financial responsibility requirements in a state you are visiting are higher than your policy limits, your insurance company will typically automatically meet those higher minimum requirements while you are in that state.
• Mexico Exclusion: Most U.S. auto policies do not provide coverage in Mexico. If you plan to drive into Mexico, you must purchase separate Mexican auto insurance.
• Out-of-State Coverage Check: It’s always wise to confirm your out-of-state coverage with your insurer before you travel.

California’s Financial Responsibility Law (California Vehicle Code Section 16020 and following) mandates that all drivers must be able to financially cover damages they cause in an accident. The minimum required coverage in California is:

• $15,000 for injury or death of one person in an accident.
• $30,000 for injury or death of two or more people in one accident.
• $5,000 for property damage in one accident.

You may be asked to show proof of financial responsibility (usually proof of insurance) if you are stopped by law enforcement or involved in an accident. You can record your insurance company name and policy number on your vehicle registration card for easy proof. Keep your proof of insurance in your car at all times when driving. Contact the California Department of Motor Vehicles for more information about financial responsibility laws.

Q. What should I do if I get sued after a car accident?

A. If you are served with a lawsuit (Summons and Complaint) related to a car accident, act immediately:

• Notify Your Agent and Insurance Company Immediately. This is crucial.
• Send Documents: Keep a copy of the lawsuit documents for your records. Send the original documents to your insurance company by mail or hand-delivery.
• Do Not Discuss the Case: Do not give statements or discuss the accident with anyone except verified representatives from your insurance company or your attorney.
• Legal Defense: If the lawsuit arises from a covered accident, your insurance company is obligated to provide you with a legal defense (lawyer) at no cost to you, as part of your policy coverage.

Q. Is a new car automatically covered under my existing policy?

A. Yes, in most cases, auto insurance policies provide automatic, temporary coverage for newly acquired vehicles.

• Replacement Vehicle: If you buy a new car to replace a vehicle already listed on your policy, the new car is usually automatically covered with the same coverages you had on the old car. However, you must notify your agent or insurance company as soon as possible about the replacement vehicle.
• Additional Vehicle: Most policies also offer automatic, temporary coverage when you add a new car to your household (you now own more cars than before). Specific conditions usually apply.
• Notification Time Limits: Most automatic coverage provisions require you to notify your insurer within a certain timeframe (often 14 to 30 days, but some policies have shorter periods) of acquiring the new vehicle if you want it permanently added to your policy. If you miss the notification deadline, the new vehicle will not be insured after the automatic coverage period ends.
• Verbal Notice: Unless your policy specifies a particular notice method, a verbal notification to your insurance agent is generally considered sufficient to activate the automatic coverage for a newly acquired vehicle.

Back to Top

Things to Avoid After a Car Accident

• Don’t Argue at the Scene: Avoid arguments or heated discussions with other drivers or passengers.
• Limit Your Statements: Save the details of the accident for the police and your insurance company.
• Do Not Admit Fault or Promise Payment: Never sign statements accepting fault or promising to pay for the other party’s damages at the scene.
• Be Wary of Deductible Offers: If another party offers to pay your deductible at the scene, be cautious and do not sign anything without consulting your insurer.
• Provide Required Information: Do not refuse to share necessary information like your driver’s license, insurance details, and vehicle information with other drivers and law enforcement.

Important Tips After a Car Accident

1. Read Your Policy Now. Don’t wait until after an accident to understand your coverage.
2. Seek Clarification. If you don’t understand any part of your policy, ask your agent or insurance company for clear explanations.
3. Call the Authorities. In case of an accident, call the police. If there are injuries, call paramedics immediately.
4. Gather Comprehensive Information. Collect as much information as possible at the accident scene to provide to your agent and insurer.
5. Report Accidents Promptly. Immediately notify your insurance agent and/or insurance company after an accident.
6. Cooperate with Adjusters. Work with insurance adjusters and investigators to assist their claim processing efforts.
7. Ask Questions About Claims. If you are unsure about any aspect of the claims process, like settlement offers, ask your agent or insurance representative for clarification.
8. Update Vehicle Ownership Changes. Notify your agent or insurance company in writing about any changes in your vehicle ownership (buying, selling, or replacing a car).

Your Rights Under California’s Fair Claims Settlement Practices Regulations

California has Fair Claims Settlement Practices Regulations to protect insurance consumers. Here’s a summary of key insurer obligations:

• Inform You of Policy Provisions: Insurers must advise you of all benefits, coverages, time limits, and other relevant provisions in your insurance policy.
• Acknowledge and Investigate Claims Promptly: Within 15 days of receiving your claim notice (oral or written communication indicating you want to file a claim), insurers must acknowledge your claim, start their investigation, provide necessary claim forms and instructions, and offer reasonable assistance.
• Respond to Your Communications Quickly: Insurers must respond to your communications immediately, but no later than 15 days after receiving them.
• Decide on Claims Within Time Limits: Insurers must accept or deny your claim promptly, but no later than 40 days after receiving your “proof of claim.” Proof of claim is documentation you provide to support your claim’s validity and amount of loss (e.g., repair estimates, police reports, etc.).
• Reasonable Towing Expenses: Unless your insurer provided you with a specific towing company recommendation before you used a towing service, they must pay reasonable towing expenses.
• Fair Settlement Offers: Insurers must offer fair settlements. For total loss claims, settlements must include applicable taxes, license fees, and transfer fees. The settlement should reflect the value of a comparable vehicle of similar kind and quality. If you keep the salvage, deductions for salvage value must be fair, measurable, and clearly explained.
• Timely Claim Payments: Once a claim is accepted and settlement is agreed upon, insurers must pay the claim promptly, but no later than 30 days from the settlement date.
• Subrogation Information and Deductible Recovery: Insurers must inform you if they will pursue subrogation. If they do, they must include your deductible in their recovery efforts (unless you’ve already recovered it yourself).

This is a simplified overview. For complete details, refer to the full text of California’s Fair Claims Settlement Practices Regulations.

Back to Top

Understanding Automobile Insurance Fraud

Automobile insurance fraud is a serious issue in California, taking various forms, primarily involving vehicle property and staged accidents.

Automobile Property Fraud: This often involves unethical practices by body shops, repair shops, or even insured individuals:

• Inflated Damage Reports: Claiming parts were damaged or missing when they weren’t.
• Exceeding Estimates: Final repair costs exceeding the original estimate without valid reason.
• Unauthorized Repairs: Billing for repairs not authorized by the customer or insurer.
• Fake OEM Parts: Charging for genuine Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) parts but using cheaper aftermarket or used parts.
• “Paper Repairs”: Pounding out dents or using body filler (Bondo) while billing for new part replacements.
• False Claims (Theft/Vandalism): Falsely reporting vehicle theft or vandalism to collect insurance money.

Protect Yourself: Always carefully review all paperwork from body and repair shops to guard against fraud. Be wary of shops that aggressively refer you to specific medical or legal offices – this could be a sign of “capping,” an illegal referral scheme in California.

Automobile Accident Fraud: This often involves organized accident rings staging fake car accidents:

• “Swoop and Squat”: Suddenly stopping for no reason, causing a rear-end collision.
• “Paper Accidents”: Accidents that exist only on paper, with no actual collision, to generate fraudulent claims.
• Staged Right-of-Way Accidents: Intentionally disregarding or yielding right-of-way to cause a collision.
• Phantom Passengers/Witnesses: Claiming passengers were in the car who weren’t, or using fake witnesses.
• Exaggerated Injuries: Claiming injuries that are disproportionate to the vehicle damage.
• Suspicious Vehicle Indicators: Temporary vehicle registrations or pre-existing damage on the other vehicle involved in the accident.
• Unsolicited Attorney Contact: Being contacted by an attorney without you initiating contact.

Be Alert: If you’re in an accident, be cautious of unsolicited referrals to body shops, law firms, or medical clinics. Organized fraud rings actively recruit participants to stage accidents, sometimes even “paper accidents” to avoid physical risk and police scrutiny.

Back to Top

Choosing Auto Body Repair Shops

California law (Insurance Code §758.5) protects your right to choose your own repair shop. Your insurance company cannot mandate that you use a specific shop. However, they can recommend shops under these legal conditions:

• Consumer Request: You specifically ask the insurer for a repair shop recommendation.
• Written Right to Choose Notice: You are informed in writing of your right to select any repair shop you prefer.
• Restoration Guarantee at Recommended Shop: If you choose a recommended shop, the insurer must guarantee that the vehicle will be restored to its pre-accident condition at no extra cost to you (beyond policy terms or legal allowances).
• Written Notice After Oral Recommendation: If the insurer orally recommends a shop and you agree, they must follow up with the legally required written notice within five calendar days.

Your Choice, Your Rights: If you choose a repair shop of your own, the insurance company must pay the reasonable costs to repair your car according to accepted industry standards for good and workmanlike repairs.

• No Discounting Based on Recommended Shops: Insurers are prohibited from reducing or discounting repair costs based on what repairs might have cost at their recommended shop.
• Insurer Responsibility for Recommended Shop Repairs: If you use a shop recommended by the insurer, the insurer is responsible for ensuring the repairs are done correctly.

Understanding Auto Replacement Parts

Auto repairs sometimes involve replacing damaged parts with aftermarket parts (parts not made by the original vehicle manufacturer). Aftermarket parts can be of equal or even superior quality to Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) parts.

• Comparable Quality Required: While aftermarket parts can be used, California law mandates that any such parts must be comparable to OEM parts in terms of kind, quality, safety, fit, and performance.
• Written Repair Estimates and Invoices: By law, repair shops must give you a written repair estimate before starting work and a written repair invoice after completion.
• Parts Identification on Invoice: State law requires repair invoices to clearly identify the type of auto parts used: used, reconditioned, rebuilt, aftermarket, or OEM. Always carefully check your invoice to ensure parts are correctly identified.

Back to Top

Important Tips (Spanish Overview) – Consejos importantes

Resumen rápido para nuestros lectores de español. ¿Qué sigue después de un accidente?

1. Lea su póliza. No espere hasta tener un accidente.
2. Pida aclaraciones. Si no entiende su póliza, pida una aclaración a su agente o compañía de seguros.
3. Llame a la autoridad. Si tiene un accidente, llame a la policía. Si hay heridos, llame a los paramédicos.
4. Recopile información. Obtenga la mayor cantidad de información posible en el lugar del accidente, para entregarla a su agente y/o compañía de seguros.
5. Notifique el accidente. Notifique inmediatamente a su agente y/o compañía de seguros si tiene un accidente.
6. Coopere con los ajustadores. Coopere con los tasadores e investigadores de la compañía de seguros.
7. Pregunte sobre el proceso de reclamos. Si no entiende algo sobre el procedimiento de reclamos, por ejemplo, la cantidad de la oferta de liquidación, pida a su agente y/o compañía de seguros que se lo expliquen.
8. Informe cambios de vehículo. Notifique por escrito a su agente o compañía de seguros cualquier cambio en la propiedad de su vehículo.

Talk to the Department of Insurance

The California Department of Insurance (CDI) is the state agency regulating the insurance industry and protecting consumer rights. Contact the CDI if:

• You feel you’ve been treated unfairly by an agent, broker, or insurance company.
• You have questions or concerns about health insurance.
• You want to order CDI brochures.
• You want to file a Request for Assistance against your agent, broker, or insurer.
• You are having difficulty starting a claim.
• You need to verify the license of an agent, broker, or insurance company.

Back to Top

Contact the CDI:

Call:

Consumer Hotline 1-800-927-4357

TDD 1-800-482-4833

Write:

California Department of Insurance

300 South Spring St., South Tower, Los Angeles, CA 90013

Visit in person:

300 South Spring St., South Tower, 9th Floor, Los Angeles, CA 90013

8:00 AM to 5:00 PM, Monday to Friday, except holidays

Back to Top