For those considering making the switch to electric vehicles, concerns about running costs often surface, with repair expenses ranking high alongside purchase price and charging infrastructure. While worries about increased maintenance costs for EVs are generally overstated – thanks to fewer moving parts and no need for oil changes, leading to lower maintenance over time – the question of collision repair costs remains. So, in the event of an accident, do electric cars actually cost more to repair than their gasoline counterparts?
Understanding Average Electric Vehicle Repair Costs
Recent findings from a study published in Automotive News, utilizing data from collision repair industry software provider Mitchell, shed light on this very issue. The study compared average collision repair costs between EVs and all vehicles across the industry. The results were reassuring: electric vehicles do incur slightly higher repair costs on average, but the difference is not as drastic as some might expect. The average repair bill for an EV was $4,474, only marginally higher – about 6 percent – than the overall average of $4,205 for all types of vehicles. This suggests that for typical fender-benders and minor accidents, EV owners are unlikely to face significantly higher repair bills compared to owners of internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles.
However, the data did highlight a notable exception: Tesla. Mitchell’s analysis indicated that the average repair cost for a Tesla after a collision was considerably higher, reaching $5,552. This figure is approximately 27 percent greater than the average repair cost across all vehicles. Several factors contribute to this disparity in Tesla repair expenses. Tesla employs innovative manufacturing techniques, such as large single-piece castings (“gigacastings”), which enhance production efficiency and reduce vehicle weight. However, these large components are more expensive to replace compared to traditional, smaller body panels used in conventional car manufacturing. Furthermore, Teslas are equipped with a high degree of advanced technology, including sophisticated camera and sensor systems. Repairing and recalibrating these intricate systems following a collision adds to both the cost of parts and the labor involved, pushing up the overall repair bill compared to vehicles with less complex technology.
Factors Influencing Electric Car Repair Costs
Several elements contribute to the slightly elevated repair costs associated with electric vehicles. One key factor is the relative novelty of EVs in the mainstream automotive market. While EV market share is growing, projected to reach around 10 percent this year, the availability of aftermarket parts for EVs is still less extensive compared to traditional vehicles that have been in production for decades. This limited aftermarket ecosystem can sometimes lead to higher prices for genuine manufacturer parts.
Moreover, the specialized nature of electric vehicle technology necessitates specific equipment and training for repair technicians. Consequently, EV repairs often need to be carried out at manufacturer-certified body shops that have invested in the required tools and training. This can potentially limit repair options and may contribute to higher labor costs compared to repairs at general auto body shops.
A less frequent but potentially very expensive scenario is battery damage. While battery damage in collisions is not common, if an EV battery is damaged and requires replacement, it can substantially inflate the overall repair cost. In fact, the high cost of EV battery replacement is a contributing factor to EVs being more likely to be written off as total losses by insurance companies after accidents compared to gasoline vehicles.
Despite these factors, the data from Automotive News and Mitchell suggests that widespread concerns about dramatically higher repair costs for electric cars are largely unfounded. These concerns are often amplified by anecdotal social media stories focusing on rare and extreme cases, such as full battery replacements. Industry-wide averages indicate that, while slightly more expensive currently, EV repair costs are not significantly higher than those for gasoline cars. As electric vehicles become more prevalent on the roads and the repair ecosystem matures, it is anticipated that EV repair costs will become even more competitive and potentially decrease further over time.
* Consult your dealership for specific limited warranty details.
